Topic: The Discussions Thread

[Kathy]

Any chance of the reviews I added to the Movie Review forum being added? Pretty please....

If you talk about the ones you have sent the first days of your registration the answer is no. I only archive the reviews written for our website on the list... Sorry, it's the only part of the board where there are rules.

Any chance you could make an exception in this case? Sam was new when he posted and wasn't aware of this. The reason I ask is I like to go to the reviews list to buy my DVDs and there were a few Sam reviewed that interested me.

[samuelrichardscott]

No worries but I do think it's a shame I don't see any post not allowing them though. If you mean just because they are on different sites, when I write a review I have a tendancy to post on all communities I'm a part of which can be as many as 5 sites.

btw, Black Book and Black Dahlia are listed incorrectly (not in alphabetical order with black 'other')

[Antares]

Any chance of the reviews I added to the Movie Review forum being added? Pretty please....

If you talk about the ones you have sent the first days of your registration the answer is no. I only archive the reviews written for our website on the list... Sorry, it's the only part of the board where there are rules.

Any chance you could make an exception in this case? Sam was new when he posted and wasn't aware of this. The reason I ask is I like to go to the reviews list to buy my DVDs and there were a few Sam reviewed that interested me.

I second this.

[Jimmy]

btw, Black Book and Black Dahlia are listed incorrectly (not in alphabetical order with black 'other')

Thanks the correction are done

I second this.

As I wrote to Kathy there is a reason for this. I can't make exceptions for one person or every new members would ask the same. Nothing prevent to post them, but the forum and the index aren't the same thing (the index is use to show the review on the homepage and that's why I prefer to keep the reviews written for DVDC).

I do like this since I created the index more than 2 years ago and I won't change my way of doing it. Sorry...

[Jimmy]

Review update

Dragonfire - L.A. Confidential
Dragonfire - Toy Story 2
Dragonfire - Toy Story 3
Dragonfire - Young Sherlock Holmes
Dragonfire - Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone
Dragonfire - A Bug's Life
Dragonfire - Strangers on a Train
Dragonfire - Cars
Dragonfire - Marmaduke
Dragonfire - Finding Nemo
Dragonfire - The Incredibles
Dragonfire - The Karate Kid (2010)

snowcat - The Royal Tenenbaums
snowcat - Hard Eight

Antares - Shakespeare in Love
Antares - The Hustler
Antares - Inherit the Wind
Antares - All About Eve

KinkyCyborg - Hot Rod
KinkyCyborg - D.E.B.S.
KinkyCyborg - 3 Godfathers
KinkyCyborg - P.S. I Love You
KinkyCyborg - Little Fish
KinkyCyborg - Saving Private Ryan
KinkyCyborg - Fandango
KinkyCyborg - In Cold Blood

dfmorgan - Castle in the Sky
dfmorgan - Grave of the Fireflies
dfmorgan - The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
dfmorgan - My Neighbour Totoro
dfmorgan - Kiki's Delivery Service

addicted2dvd - White Zombie
addicted2dvd - The Brave One
addicted2dvd - Cave Girl
addicted2dvd - BloodRayne
addicted2dvd - War of the Robots
addicted2dvd - One Frightened Night
addicted2dvd - Ratatouille
addicted2dvd - Scooby-Doo and the Legend of the Vampire
addicted2dvd - Spider-Man 3

Tom - Kya Kehna!
Tom - The Godfather
Tom - Forrest Gump
Tom - Na Tum Jaano Na Hum
Tom - The Other End of the Line
Tom - Monsoon Wedding
Tom - Up
Tom - The Adventures of Sharkboy and Lavagirl
Tom - Zoom: Academy for Superheroes
Tom - Thunderbirds

Achim - Family Plot

samuelrichardscott - Dumb and Dumber
samuelrichardscott - Detroit Rock City
samuelrichardscott - Dead Scared
samuelrichardscott - Dead Calm
samuelrichardscott - Meet the Parents
samuelrichardscott - Meet the Fockers
samuelrichardscott - 3-Way
samuelrichardscott - Kiss Kiss Bang Bang
samuelrichardscott - Hail the Conquering Hero

Critter - Get Him to the Greek
Critter - Toy Story

Jon - The Dead Pool
Jon - The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Jon - The Karate Kid (2010)

[Jimmy]

Review update for this week

KinkyCyborg - The Murders in the Rue Morgue (1986)
KinkyCyborg - The Shaggy Dog
KinkyCyborg - Hud
KinkyCyborg - Dumb And Dumberer: When Harry Met Lloyd
KinkyCyborg - Good Will Hunting
KinkyCyborg - X-15

Dragonfire - The Adventures of Robin Hood (1938)
Dragonfire - Dial M for Murder 
Dragonfire - A Perfect Murder 
Dragonfire - Rear Window
Dragonfire - The World is Not Enough
Dragonfire - Disturbia
Dragonfire - Die Another Day
Dragonfire - Superman Batman: Public Enemies
Dragonfire - WALL-E 
Dragonfire - G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra
Dragonfire - Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
Dragonfire - Knight and Day
Dragonfire - Independence Day

Tom - My Name Is Khan
Tom - Karan Arjun
Tom - The New Guy
Tom - Zatoichi
Tom - All Over Me
Tom - Mujhse Dosti Karoge
Tom - Galaxy Quest

Critter - Toy Story 3
Critter - X-Men
Critter - Ratatouille
Critter - New Moon

dfmorgan - Only Yesterday
dfmorgan - 2012
dfmorgan - Alice in Wonderland
dfmorgan - The Book Of Eli
dfmorgan - Collateral

Antares - The Manchurian Candidate (1962)

RossRoy - The Revenge of Doctor X
RossRoy - The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus
RossRoy - Dead Man
RossRoy - Jesse James Meets Frankenstein's Daughter
RossRoy - Up
RossRoy - Street Fighter: The Legend of Chun-Li
RossRoy - Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone
RossRoy - Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
RossRoy - Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban

snowcat - Drilbit Taylor
snowcat - Once
snowcat - Zoolander
snowcat - Gone With the Wind

Hal - Adam Had Four Sons
Hal - Ronin
Hal - Watchmen
Hal - 8 1/2
Hal - Firewall
Hal - Black Narcissus
Hal - Carnal Knowledge

goodguy - Silent Hill
goodguy - Elizabeth
goodguy - Elizabeth: The Golden Age
goodguy - The Secret of Kells

Achim - Centurion

addicted2dvd - Best Men
addicted2dvd - Clash of the Titans
addicted2dvd - Daddy Day Care
addicted2dvd - Enter the Dragon
addicted2dvd - Fight Club
addicted2dvd - It's Complicated
addicted2dvd - Jocks

Rogmeister - Zoom: Academy for Superheroes
Rogmeister - The Duel at Silver Creek

Jon - M
Jon - The Fountain
Jon - Bicycle Thieves

Eric - 2012

Jimmy - Les 7 jours du talion

[Jimmy]

Update for this week

dfmorgan - Porco Rosso
dfmorgan - Duplicity
dfmorgan - Eastern Promises
dfmorgan - Forgetting Sarah Marshall
dfmorgan - Gamer
dfmorgan - Robo Geisha
dfmorgan - The House Bunny
dfmorgan - Inkheart

Tom - 12:01
Tom - Vivah
Tom - Jaane Tu... Ya Jaane Na
Tom - Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam
Tom - What's Cooking?

snowcat - Memento

Hal - The Devil & Daniel Webster
Hal - Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
Hal - Gandhi
Hal - Hopscotch
Hal - Ikiru
Hal - Juno

KinkyCyborg - Better Than Sex
KinkyCyborg - Inglourious Basterds
KinkyCyborg - After Sundown
KinkyCyborg - The Naked Gun: From the Files of Police Squad!
KinkyCyborg - The Detective
KinkyCyborg - Unknown
KinkyCyborg - The White Countess
KinkyCyborg - Light Sleeper

Jon - Night of The Hunter
Jon - Airplane!
Jon - Harry Potter and The Half-Blood Prince
Jon - The Kite Runner
Jon - Island of Fire
Jon - The Dirty Dozen
Jon - The Omen II: Damien
Jon - The Yakuza

RossRoy - Fanboys
RossRoy - The Voyeur
RossRoy - I Am Legend
RossRoy - Enchanted
RossRoy - Bitch Slap

Dragonfire - To Catch a Thief   
Dragonfire - Casino Royale
Dragonfire - Ratatouille
Dragonfire - The Last Airbender

goodguy - Gone with the Wind
goodguy - Der freie Wille
goodguy - Mouth to Mouth

addicted2dvd - K-PAX
addicted2dvd - The Lady Vanishes
addicted2dvd - Meet Dave
addicted2dvd - Nine to Five
addicted2dvd - Operation Pacific
addicted2dvd - The Parent Trap
addicted2dvd - Ready To Rumble
addicted2dvd - Short Circuit
addicted2dvd - Twister
addicted2dvd - Universal Soldier
addicted2dvd - Vertigo
addicted2dvd - X-Men 2
addicted2dvd - Young and Innocent
addicted2dvd - Zorro's Black Whip
addicted2dvd - The Parent Trap II
addicted2dvd - Knight Rider Pilot Movie

Rogmeister - Stagecoach
Rogmeister - Outlaw Women
Rogmeister - Waterhole #3
Rogmeister - 20 Million Miles To Earth

Eric - 5150, Rue des Ormes

Achim - Predators
Achim - Assault on Precinct 13

Rick - The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford

Critter - The Princess and the Frog
Critter - The Queen

addicted2comics() - 13 Ghosts
addicted2comics() - Annie
addicted2comics() - Bratz: Genie Magic
addicted2comics() - Catwoman

[Jimmy]

Very important message

This is my last update for the index. After more than 2 years of work and regular update I've lost a lot of interest in this. Actually Karsten or Sebastien are the only one who can continue the works (they are moderators), but if someone else is interested I can give him/her some explanations after he/she will became the moderator of this area.

I understand it looks like this decision came out of the blue, but it's been a while since I first think about this and my decision is irrevocable this time.

I really hope that someone else will relieve me and continue. It would be sad to see this feature die because of a lack of interest from anyone else.

[Tom]

If noone else will wants to do it, I would be willing to take over.
The review index is one of the best features of this site and I regularly use it. I think it is worth the effort.
Thank you, Jimmy, for starting it and doing the work until now 

[RossRoy]

I could take over, as I read pretty much all reviews, so updating a list shouldn't be too much of a hassle.

[Najemikon]

You've done a cracking job, Jimmy, thank you. I'd have a go, but for time and commitment. You will still be contributing though, eh?

[Jimmy]

I attach the text file I use for it, not that it's that complicated since it's mostly a copy and paste job.

Thanks guys for showing an interest to continue the index, it's really appreciated

You will still be contributing though, eh?

I'm sure you have seen that I don't write a lot of review anymore (I'm not even sure if I wrote at least 10 of them this year). But don't worry I will do my october marathon with every movies reviewed again this year.

[RossRoy]

Jimmy, are you up to date, as of right now?

[Jimmy]

The first new one since my update is the Brittany review of The Derby Stallion

[snowcat]

Thanks for doing what you did Jimmy, I understand that this kind of thing is hard work.