I love Donnie Darko and think it's one of the best films of the last ten years. I watched it with several friends at the cinema and we all had different ideas about what had actually happened, discussed it in detail and went and watched it again the next night and had different opinions on what had happened on that viewing. Director's Cut spoilt it in my opinion and I haven't seen S. Darko yet.
I saw Martian Child July 25th 2009 and my note was:- John Cusack is very good in this but unfortunately the boy who plays the 'martian child' just wasn't a good choice for the role. Decent story if formulaic. 3/5
I like Signs and don't think it was the start of the decline. But that's only because Shyamalan's flaws were always there! Signs was the first film that couldn't hide them. When I first saw Unbreakable I thought it was a fantastic twist on the superhero formula and the determination not to use a set-piece or extravagant action was so refreshing. But in Signs there is a scene that reveals he simply can't do action or hold tension within a shot. For me the sequence where (click to show/hide)the alien is confronted in the house and Gibson realises the connection with the water and Phoenix stood under his baseball bat just doesn't work. They just seem to stare at each other until a near zombified Phoenix finally reacts! That always annoyed me. Still, his films look great and I loved the early glimpses of the creatures. Film4 here in the UK are showing two of his films on TV next week. The promo advertised Sixth Sense for Friday and The Happening for Saturday, and follows up with an interview with Shyamalan, the "Auteur". Their words.
I like the first two acts of Signs very much, but think that it falls apart in the third. (click to show/hide)Aliens that have a problem with water trying to invade a planet which has its surface covered 70% by oceans...? It did show that it was the beginning of the decline. What was next...? The Village (one good act and then falls apart from the second onwards), Lady in the Water and The Happening. I absolutely adore The Sixth Sense (throws dust in my eyes every time) and agree that Unbreakable was a very interesting twist (SPOILER) on the superhero genre.
The moment you speak of in your Spoiler tag didn't bother me as it played out more like a Mexican standoff with (click to show/hide)the alien realizing his predicament, having been left behind and knowing the child was his only leverage then those final moments with his wife and her cryptic last words came to him at that moment which led Gibson to tell Phoenix to 'Swing Away'. It was the old "Everything happens for a reason' cliche but it was necessary to help restore the priest's faith.I too loved how little you see of the invaders up until that moment which greatly built up the suspense which I think helps set Signs apart from most other Alien type movies where their scary visages are front and center.Would be curious to hear some of Shyamalan's thoughts of his early movies. I still haven't watched The Happening yet.
I like the first two acts of Signs very much, but think that it falls apart in the third. (click to show/hide)Aliens that have a problem with water trying to invade a planet which has its surface covered 70% by oceans...?