Topic: Our movie rating system

[Tom]

Because we have now a lot of new members, I thought I would introduce our "DCO rating system" for our reviews. Of course it is not obligatory to use it (not all of us do).

There is a button on the "post reply" page called "Encore rating 5=Best, 0=Worst" (right next to the WhatYaGot buttons). It will insert "mr" tags and the number you will enter in-between them is your rating and will be mapped to the correct smiley.
The ratings are:
0 = (bad or worse)
1 = (boring)
2 = (not really bad, but not good either)
3 = (I enjoyed it)
4 = (now that was quite good)
5 = (Excellent!)

You can roughly think of it as a star rating going from 0 to 5 stars.


@Karsten: Maybe we should pin it somewhere. You are welcome to move my post or make a new post with a better wording and remove mine.

[mrubs]

Nice, i like this.
What about these 

 
 

[Jimmy]

Nothing prevent you to use any system you want (of course I love the current one as I was the creator of it ), but you won't be able to use the icon to do it automatically.

[Achim]

Nice, i like this.
What about these  

 
 

What the hell was that...? (Whoa...)
What the hell was that (WTF)
I don't get it...
Abolute winner!

Good additions, but as Jimmy said, the others basically represent a scale from 0-5, so others will be outside of that.

[mrubs]

Ok, Forget about all this smiles and why not back to the original movie rating system...

G — General Audiences. All Ages Admitted.
PG — Parental Guidance Suggested. Some Material May Not Be Suitable For Children.
PG-13 — Parents Strongly Cautioned. Some Material May Be Inappropriate For Children Under 13.
R — Restricted. Children Under 17 Require Accompanying Parent or Adult Guardian.
NC-17 — No One 17 and Under Admitted.

But i don't like this very much

[Jimmy]

Because this had nothing to do with movie rating... it's a movie review system

[Mustrum_Ridcully]

Because this had nothing to do with movie rating... it's a movie review system

... and it would apply for US-citizens only

[Jimmy]

Right

If an official movie rating system would be used here it would be the german one as the website is host in Germany

and we would be force to post our review like that

[DJ Doena]

The german rating system in a nutshell:

FSK-12: The good guy gets the girl.
FSK-16: The bad guy gets the girl.
FSK-18: Everyone gets the girl.

[Jimmy]

That would not work with the last two movies I purchased

[Najemikon]

The german rating system in a nutshell:

FSK-12: The good guy gets the girl.
FSK-16: The bad guy gets the girl.
FSK-18: Everyone gets the girl.

 

[mrubs]

Because this had nothing to do with movie rating... it's a movie review system

I think you don't see my attachment, forget that. One thig, you said you purchased two movie (lolz).
I don't remember when should i purchased a movie.
See my horror collections (it's only the part of horror collections, lol)

[Najemikon]

One thig, you said you purchased two movie (lolz).
I don't remember when should i purchased a movie.

Oh yeah! You're the guy that steals films. "lolz"

[Jimmy]

I think you don't see my attachment, forget that. One thig, you said you purchased two movie (lolz).

Are you an idiot

Seriously I haven't seen you contribute anything here except the post where you were so proud to have stole 36 movies

Do you really think I give a fuck about your picture... Wich by the way had far more TV stuff than horror and is incredibly small for a photography taken by yourself...

Maybe you should use the spam link in your avatar and your link to learn some language skills as you fail to understand a simple fact like the difference between the MPAA rating and a film review system.

Usually I'm a patient guy, but when I see a newbie who use a spam link as signature, who don't post anything usefull, who had the nerve to critic a system working for years in a website, who is a thief and who sound like a spam robot I tend to lost my nerves.

So try to be usefull before criticizing the procedure already well etablished on a website or if this is too hard for you try imdb as they have no problem with useless spambot.

[Blair]

I like my system best