my bumpy little reviews
I expected more of this movie. But it was rather dull. There were a few funny scenes, but in general the movie was very uneven.
Interesting, because I felt the same. I saw it at the cinema and decided to give it another run on DVD, but it just doesn't seem to be good enough. It is good, just not enough... I did wonder if I was jaded by too much Judd Apatow. I really liked Knocked Up but pretty much ruined it by watching the second disc. Superbad has a similar problem. As you almost certainly realise, Apatow's films are largely ad libbed which works brilliantly, but there is a huge amount of b-roll footage which they include on the second disc. It can be funny, but it's just the same scenes endlessly played, often going in angles that they surely knew could never be used. Eventually you get seriously sick of it.
I agree, if reviews tried to sell it as something sophisticated then they were probably reading too much into it. I even doubt they were going for that, there were just having fun.Comparing it to American Pie in such way is a bit rough though... I mean I enjoy American Pie just as the next guy, but it is way more juvenile than Superbad.