I only saw the DC od DD and still was mightily confused about what was going on in that movie....
Quote from: DJ Doena on April 27, 2010, 06:37:01 AMI only saw the DC of DD and still was mightily confused about what was going on in that movie....So you can only imagine what the Theatrical was like
I only saw the DC of DD and still was mightily confused about what was going on in that movie....
Oh yeah? Coming from Missus "Let's discuss Fargo"! But seriously, yes, it would be a good thread.Have you ever heard the story about Alfred Hitchcock's granddaughter and To Catch A Thief? I think it was his granddaughter anyway. She was asked in school to write an essay on To Catch A Thief. Obviously, she went to see Gramps and he gave her a few pointers. Despite help from the director of the film, she got a disappointing "C"! The teacher then explained her mistakes.Dejected, she went back to Hitch. He just shrugged his shoulders and said, "Well, that's what I thought it meant..." That just sums up what a genius he was and how well he understood film, that he didn't feel he should be precious about his own work.
after all, I always think the story should be... uhh, In the mind of the beholder
I guess it must have happened more than once that a director was asked about the meaning of what a certain image held, with loads of possible interpretations, and he may have just thought it looks cool Often I read reviews with the wildest interpretations and I can only doubt that the director had all those complicated thoughts about certain things in his film. I lack strong examples right now, but I think you'll know.
Ive heard that story, it made me laugh.... Its one of those things, when you are at school and you read a book, if you disagree with the meaning that your teacher gives, then you are obviously wrong!
Quote from: Achim on April 27, 2010, 05:26:15 PMI guess it must have happened more than once that a director was asked about the meaning of what a certain image held, with loads of possible interpretations, and he may have just thought it looks cool Often I read reviews with the wildest interpretations and I can only doubt that the director had all those complicated thoughts about certain things in his film. I lack strong examples right now, but I think you'll know. I know what you mean. I usually feel this way about movies where people interpret a lot of things into it, but I think that the director did not exactly had anything specific in mind. I doubt that David Lynch can make sense of his own movies.The same thing about art. In school we were asked to interpret paintings, but I always felt the artist just wanted to make a living and tried to make the painting look cool and/or experimented with techniques.