Topic: Horror Mansion Survival Game Questions

[SailorRipley]

Ok, I thought about making up this thread in case everybody has some questions or ideas for the Horror Mansion Survival game.

Currently, Rick asks if he can make questions for the trivia or have clues. I think it would be fair, although the clues would have to be done in such a way that they don't give the answer away. For now, I have allowed it.

What do you guys think?

[Najemikon]

Essentially, I think yes. BUT, who would give the clues? I would not allow assistance from the killer and only from people in the same room.

[lyonsden5]

I would say one question would be in order.

Or a generic clue (like the one you gave me)

Not sure about both though.

[RossRoy]

There's so many movies out there and so many subject to choose from, and it's really hard to know who will have seen what, so yeah, give the victim to 1, maybe 2 additional clues, if needed.

Maybe asking for clues could restrict their movement freedom, and remove points if they survive or something.

[Kathy]

I must vote for this because I would have been dead if the killer had chosen me. I knew the scene, have watched the movie more than once, and STILL couldn't have answered!  I hate those “senior moments”!

[Achim]

Well, some of you seem to have a question already, while I haven't (expecting to have one coming in shortly... depending...).

I'll leave my vote until I see the level of question that Sailor comes up with.

EDIT:
Expected to be the question via PM, but now saw it's in the other thread... I think one hint should be allowed. After that, the person under attack is.... all alone.

[SailorRipley]

Essentially, I think yes. BUT, who would give the clues? I would not allow assistance from the killer and only from people in the same room.

I think the best bet is to leave the clues to the host.

I would say one question would be in order. Or a generic clue (like the one you gave me)

Not sure about both though.

There's so many movies out there and so many subject to choose from, and it's really hard to know who will have seen what, so yeah, give the victim to 1, maybe 2 additional clues, if needed.

Maybe asking for clues could restrict their movement freedom, and remove points if they survive or something.

Yeah, both may be too much. I think a generic clue is the best choice, with no punishment. However, if you need a second clue, you will be frozen in your current room for 1 game turn, thus becoming a potential target. What do you think of this?

[Achim]

Yeah, both may be too much. I think a generic clue is the best choice, with no punishment. However, if you need a second clue, you will be frozen in your current room for 1 game turn, thus becoming a potential target. What do you think of this?

That works for me.

[RossRoy]

Yeah, both may be too much. I think a generic clue is the best choice, with no punishment. However, if you need a second clue, you will be frozen in your current room for 1 game turn, thus becoming a potential target. What do you think of this?

Sounds good.

[Kathy]

Unanimous?!?

This is definitely not the other web site! 

[Touti]

Just came back from the trail and I haven't read the other thread yet.  I too was under the impression that all trivia questions were gonna be asked in PM in which case it would have been up to Sailor to give clues.  I'm a bit confused here.

[SailorRipley]

Just came back from the trail and I haven't read the other thread yet.  I too was under the impression that all trivia questions were gonna be asked in PM in which case it would have been up to Sailor to give clues.  I'm a bit confused here.

Oh absolutely, all questions are asked via PM. The only reason I posted the question at the 'official' thread is so everybody could know what was going and comment on it. The clue thing came up because I wanted you all to have a saying in if it should be a fair thing or not.

[lyonsden5]

hypothetically . . . 

If someone doesn't answer the question can one of the others answer it? Perhaps get some anti-zombie spray (single use canister of course) for a correct answer and paralizing you (loose a turn) for a wrong answer? (losing a turn would most likely mean you are next in line for an attack as the killer can move to where you are 

Just a thought 

[RossRoy]

hypothetically . . . 

Feeling queazy about the question? Mwahahahaha! 

[lyonsden5]

Oooo - new avatar