Whatever you do don't watch Ally Farson: Confessed Murderess: "My Private Life". Sorority is Oscar worthy compared to this one. Do yourself a favor and throw the DVD away and keep the case.
Which version of Alfie do you own? The original w/ Michael Caine and Shelly Winters or the one with Jude Law?
I would probably suggest either Apocalypto or American History X.
I don't know many of these. But I did enjoy "America's Sweethearts". I didn't enjoy "The Aviator" though.