Topic: Historical accuracy - Fixing the script.

[Eric]

(click to show/hide)

I forgot about the King arresting him for that.
Just remembered something else.... The real Robin was taking something back to England..the crown or Richard's sword..something very important.  The French were trying to get it.  Crowe's character came across the real Robin and was talked into returning the item to England..and then going to see his father - the real Robin's father.  The real Robin and the men with him had been attacked by the French.

(click to show/hide)

That's true, the thought had never occured to me but you're right, it's not even Robin Loxley that we follow throughout the movie.

[Dragonfire]

(click to show/hide)

That's true, the thought had never occured to me but you're right, it's not even Robin Loxley that we follow throughout the movie.

(click to show/hide)

The fact that he wasn't even really Robin Loxley is what I found to be the oddest about the movie.  Setting how he becomes an outlaw is fine.  It was also weird when he went into that final battle with that hammer looking weapon instead of using his bow and arrows as much.

[Achim]

(click to show/hide)

That's true, the thought had never occured to me but you're right, it's not even Robin Loxley that we follow throughout the movie.

(click to show/hide)

The fact that he wasn't even really Robin Loxley is what I found to be the oddest about the movie.  Setting how he becomes an outlaw is fine.  It was also weird when he went into that final battle with that hammer looking weapon instead of using his bow and arrows as much.

(click to show/hide)

But then why is the film called Robin Hood. (I haven't seen it, but since I don't intend to Iopened the spoilers...)

[Dragonfire]

(click to show/hide)

I believe they called it a retelling or revision of the Robin Hood story.  Crowe's character does basically take over the identity of Loxley.

[Achim]

Thanks, that makes it understandable.

[Eric]

(click to show/hide)

I believe they called it a retelling or revision of the Robin Hood story.  Crowe's character does basically take over the identity of Loxley.

(click to show/hide)

And that leads to the real question............................WHY ?

Why come up with that stupid story about some guy posing as Robin Hood ? 

[Dragonfire]

(click to show/hide)

I believe they called it a retelling or revision of the Robin Hood story.  Crowe's character does basically take over the identity of Loxley.

(click to show/hide)

And that leads to the real question............................WHY ?

Why come up with that stupid story about some guy posing as Robin Hood ? 

(click to show/hide)

I don't know.  That is a very good question and I wondered that too...why change that bit of the story.  Wanting to show something different before he becomes an outlaw..fine.  Have King Richard be killed.  Fine.  But an imposter Robin...I never did figure that out.

[Achim]

(click to show/hide)

I believe they called it a retelling or revision of the Robin Hood story.  Crowe's character does basically take over the identity of Loxley.

(click to show/hide)

And that leads to the real question............................WHY ?

Why come up with that stupid story about some guy posing as Robin Hood ?

(click to show/hide)

I don't know.  That is a very good question and I wondered that too...why change that bit of the story.  Wanting to show something different before he becomes an outlaw..fine.  Have King Richard be killed.  Fine.  But an imposter Robin...I never did figure that out.

(click to show/hide)

I would have to rewatch the documentary on the The Adventures of Robin Hood (1938) Blu-ray tobe certain, but I think they basically said the identity of Robin Hood was never totally verified. The Wikipedia page goes as far as saying, that it is possible that Robin Hood is entirely fictional.  So, I think that guy pretending to be Loxley and then going around as Robin Hood seems plausible to me.

[Eric]

(click to show/hide)

I would have to rewatch the documentary on the The Adventures of Robin Hood (1938) Blu-ray tobe certain, but I think they basically said the identity of Robin Hood was never totally verified. The Wikipedia page goes as far as saying, that it is possible that Robin Hood is entirely fictional.  So, I think that guy pretending to be Loxley and then going around as Robin Hood seems plausible to me.

Ok, I'm probably not doing myself a favor by showing my complete lack of culture but...........     Robin Hood is supposed to have really existed ?  I always thought it was a story  

[Eric]

Here's another very important question regarding historical accuracy.

Pride and Prejudice:  Did British women of the time all really wore those dresses that made them look like potato bags ?

[Najemikon]

Robin Hood like Arthur is a legend, so all we know about him is based on word of mouth or more accurately songs, from down the centuries. In truth there is likely a man or perhaps an amalgamation of several from which the tales were based, but he may have even just been a fantasy hero even then.

Regards the potato bag women...  I assume you mean those corsets?



Yes, they're real. Apparently they were so tight the maids tied them with brute force while the lady hung on for dear life! I believe they constricted them so much they couldn't breathe properly, hence the tendency for high class ladies to faint frequently at a slight shock. Long term they could get respiratory problems.

I thought corsets would have been just as normal in the New World though?

[Eric]

Not corsets Jon (which they did have on this side of the pond btw), I'm talking about this.  All the women in Pride and Prejudice wear them.............and it does make them look like potato bags 

[Najemikon]

Oh yes! I know what you mean now. Yes, I've seen pictures. They're genuine. Don't know what they're called though.

[Eric]

It must have been some very British fashion because I don't remember seeing dresses like that in any movie or book.

[Eric]

It occured to me that those dresses look pretty much like night gowns so I did a quick research and it turns out that they are actually called gowns.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gown