Thousands and thousands of human die each day in armed conflict everywhere, am I suppose to cry for the fate of a cow or a dog?
Jon the animals in the movie were to be kill anyway by the native since this is what they eat, the only one killed for the sake of the movie was a spider and honestly who care for a spider. I don't see any difference with this and a film crew that goes in a slaughterhouse to film what happen there or filming a chinese restaurant practice. I've gone hunting and fishing a lot of time when I was younger and I don't think that I'm an indecent or bad guy. Sure everything caught was eating at the familly table and to be honest a fresh bunny or partridge taste great.
If a director tells an actor to kill something because he needs to shock the audience then him, his actor and his film can fuck right off! It just shows a lack of talent, laziness or both because editing can achieve the same conclusion.
So is this part documentary using real natives? If so, I had no idea and although I still have no wish to see it, I can accept its methods.
Quote from: Jon on January 26, 2009, 10:03:14 AMIf a director tells an actor to kill something because he needs to shock the audience then him, his actor and his film can fuck right off! It just shows a lack of talent, laziness or both because editing can achieve the same conclusion.A lot of others director had done the same thing and they don't get any critics because of this. Just to give some names : Francis Ford Coppola, Umberto Lenzi, Bernardo Bertolucci, T.F. Mous and Sam Peckinpah. Some of them are certainly talented and they have used this in highly praised movie.
Edit : By the way this "sport" is more cruel than anything shown in this movie
I'm trying to think what examples these are though and I can't think of Peckinpah's. Regards Coppola, I can think of two; but the horse was already dead (The Godfather) and like the example that started this, the water buffalo sacrifice in Appocalypse Now was going to happen anyway as they were real natives.
Even if you don't like this genre of film you will agree that this scene is a masterpiece (Jon I'm talking to you ).
I detest this film. I've often said it's the worst I've ever seen [...]